Department of Labor Seal photos representing the workforce - digital imagery© copyright 2001 photodisc, inc.
Department of Labor Seal www.osha.gov   [skip navigational links] Search    Advanced Search | A-Z Index
OSHA Strategic Partnerships Program > Region 2 > #536 Partnership Agreement

Link to Printing InstructionsPrinting Instructions
 
Comprehensive Safety and Health Partnering Agreement
Between
Barr and Barr, Inc.
Maxim Construction Services, AJAY Glass Company, Woodcock & Armani Mechanical, H.J. Brandeles, Rich & Gardner Construction Co., Northland Associates, Inc., Island International Industries, SRI Fire Sprinkler Corporation, J&K Plumbing & Heating Co.,Inc., Syracuse Merit Electric, Inc., Fast Trek Steel, Inc., and Canatal Industries
and
United States Department of Labor
Occupational Safety & Health Administration
Region 2 – Syracuse Area Office
Partnership
Barr and Barr, Inc.

1.0 Background

In an effort to eliminate serious hazards and achieve a high level of worker safety and health for employees engaged in the construction of the Life Sciences Technology Building at Syracuse University in Syracuse, NY Barr & Barr, Inc., and the above named groups have developed a comprehensive partnering agreement. Participants include project stakeholders from government, industry employers, and labor. This partnering agreement will facilitate the process of: identifying project health and safety performance goals; developing plans for achieving those goals; cooperation in hazard control implementation; measuring and establishing a vehicle to communicate the successes; and ultimately learning from the process. Beyond the confines of this project, it is projected that this partnership agreement will foster a sustainable working relationship between OSHA, Barr & Barr, Inc., and the (signatory construction trade companies).

This partnering agreement shall be limited to OSHA Syracuse Area Office, Barr & Barr and their workforce of subcontractors. It is anticipated that at the peak of this project, Barr & Barr, Inc., .and its subcontractors will employ over 200 trades employees.

This partnership is consistent with OSHA’s long-range efforts to develop a contractor/government partnership approach to safety and health management. It allows for better use of OSHA resources, it allows for innovation in safety and health management, and it encourages more participation in the safety and health process from the construction/trade association communities.

2.0 Project History

Barr & Barr, Inc. is a construction management company headquartered in New York with a workforce of approximately 250 employees. Barr & Barr’s Framingham, Ma. office will be responsible for managing all aspects of this project.

Barr & Barr, Inc., is the construction manager responsible for the construction of the Life Sciences Technology Building at Syracuse University in Syracuse, NY. The approximately $80 million project has a tentative 29 month duration and entails the construction of a 5 story, 225,000 square foot life science building, constructed on an existing parking lot. The structure will be structural steel frame with a mechanical penthouse, and roof top Greenhouse. The façade will consist of curtain wall, punched windows, zinc metal panels and a terra cotta rain screen system. The building construction will be preceded by a mass excavation phase, where the building foundation will be between approximately 10 – 20 feet below grade.

The Project will start the summer of 2006 and is scheduled to be completed in July of 2008.

3.0 Partnership Goals and Strategies
    3.1 The goals of this Partnership include:

    1. Implementing strategies to eliminate serious accidents, including the four primary construction hazards (falls, electrical, caught in/between, and struck-by) and illnesses associated with employee exposure to crystalline silica;
    2. Developing a contractor/government partnership that will encourage local construction subcontractors involved in the projects to improve their safety and health performance;
    3. Assisting the participating local construction subcontractors in achieving the objectives listed below;
    4. Conducting contractor and subcontractor employee safety and health training;
    5. Recognizing those subcontractors with exemplary safety and health programs.
    3.2 The strategies of this Partnership include:

    1. Reducing the number of conditions that have the potential to result in worker injury/illness, property damage, and environmental impact to the lowest reasonable level;
    2. Zero (0) fatalities;
    3. Zero (0) accidents and employee exposures involving trenches and excavations without adequate cave-in protection;
    4. No employees exposed to silica above OSHA’s General Industry Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL) without utilization of feasible engineering controls, administrative controls, work practice controls and/or adequate respiratory protection;
    5. Abating hazards that are identified from weekly safety and health inspections and having no repeat occurrences of such conditions upon re-inspection;
    6. To have 100% of all employees on this project trained with an OSHA 10-hour Construction Safety & Health course or as soon as feasible of their starting work on this project. Barr & Barr, Inc. and OSHA strongly recommend that employees and supervisors have the training current within the last 5 years.
    7. z project Days Away, Restricted and Transfer (DART) rate and Total Case Incidence Rate (TCIR) rate which are 25% less than the national average for NAICS 236220 based upon the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) data available for the most current year (2004). The 2004 BLS DART rate for NAICS = 3.0 and TCIR rate for NAICS 236220 = 6.1.;
    8. Fostering a sustainable working relationship between Barr & Barr, Inc., Syracuse University, OSHA, building and construction trades, and other entities involved in this project;
4.0 Environmental, Health and Safety (EH&S) Performance Criteria
    4.1 Barr & Barr, Inc., will establish the following:

      4.1.0 Weekly Foremen’s and Stewards’ Meetings – Barr & Barr, Inc., shall hold a weekly meeting with all Foremen that shall include focused discussions addressing site safety and health issues.

      4.1.1 Monthly Meetings - Barr & Barr, Inc., shall hold a monthly principles project safety and health meeting to discuss program status and participant/subcontractor performance. OSHA is welcome to attend these meetings.

      4.1.2 Qualified Safety and Health Representatives - Barr & Barr, Inc., shall assign a qualified safety and health representative to administer its safety and health program.

      4.1.3 Risk Assessment - Barr & Barr, Inc., shall conduct a comprehensive risk assessment of project work and incorporate the findings of the assessment into the Site Specific Safety Plan.

      4.1.4 Project-specific Safety and Health Plan Guidelines - Barr & Barr, Inc., shall prepare a project-specific safety and health plan. This plan shall incorporate the following minimum elements:

      1. Comprehensive silicosis prevention program
      2. All trenches and excavations will require adequate cave-in protection
      3. Mandatory use of Ground Fault Interrupters (GFCIs) throughout the project
      4. All cranes, hoists, and scissor/aerial lifts will be 3rd party inspected and certified safe prior to use
      5. Use of appropriate personal protective equipment
      6. Site-specific safety and health training
      7. Workplace surveillance
      8. Employee involvement
      9. Management commitment
      10. Provide 100% fall protection for all employees working at heights 6 feet or more above the adjacent surface or adjacent to dangerous equipment or materials.
      4.1.5 Weekly Safety and Health Audits - Barr & Barr, Inc., shall conduct and document weekly safety and health audits to assess program performance.

      4.1.6 Training - Barr & Barr, Inc., shall help provide safety and health training resources for all project participants as needed. Another objective of this training will be to familiarize all employees with the Safety Management System. This will include the methods and contacts employees can use to address safety and health concerns. Employees should be encouraged at the time of this training, and during other safety and health – related training, to utilize this reporting system as an alternative to filing a complaint with OSHA.

      Barr & Barr, Inc., shall provide on-going safety and health training to workers that will address new projects, tasks, or processes. All workers on this project will be required to successfully complete a 10-hour construction safety course. Barr & Barr, Inc., will be responsible for ensuring that these training requirements are met for their own employees as well as overseeing that project contractors’ employees have received the requisite training pursuant Paragraph 4.2.6 of the Agreement.

      4.1.7 Incident Record Keeping Database – Barr & Barr, Inc., shall maintain a project OSHA-300 Log (or equivalent database) for work at the projects. The Log shall be maintained in accordance with 1904.19.

      4.1.8 Safety and Health Incentive Program - Barr & Barr, Inc., will implement a health and safety incentive program to assist in fostering a safe work environment. Individual employees will be rewarded with incentives for excellence in safety and health.
    4.2 Project Sub Contractor’s Role

      4.2.1 Site Specific Safety and Health Plan - All contractors shall provide a site-specific safety and health plan, which meets or exceeds Barr & Barrs’ site specific safety plan. Barr & Barr, Inc., will collect and review plans for compliance.

      4.2.2 New Hire Safety Orientation - All sub contractors shall provide new hire employees with project-specific safety and health information and instructions prior to starting work.

      4.2.3 Task-specific Weekly Toolbox Instructions - All sub contractors shall provide workers with instructions on integration of safety and health requirements with current work tasks for the week. All Subcontractors shall allow an OSHA representative to attend any of these meetings, when requested by OSHA.

      4.2.4 Qualified Safety and Health Representatives - All sub contractors shall assign a qualified safety and health representative to administer their program.

      4.2.5 Weekly Safety and Health Inspections - All sub contractors shall conduct weekly inspections of their portion of the jobsite to assess compliance with all project safety and health requirements and OSHA standards. No outstanding non-compliance issues shall be allowed to carry over into the subsequent week's inspections.

      4.2.6 Safety and Health Training - All sub contractors shall provide on-going safety and health training to workers, that will address new projects, tasks, or processes. All workers on this project will be required to successfully complete a 10-hour construction safety and health course as soon as feasible from their start work date.

      4.2.7 Record Keeping/ Documentation - All sub contractors shall maintain documentation of all safety and health activities described herein and provide copies to Barr & Barr Inc. Documentation of near misses, and the correction of hazardous conditions that were noticed due to the heightened safety and health awareness that this partnership creates, shall be completed by Barr & Barr, Inc., at least quarterly.
    4.3 OSHA’s Role

      4.3.1. Program Evaluation - Provide initial and continued review and evaluation of Barr & Barr, Inc., and other signatories compliance with the partnership agreement.

      4.3.2 Incident Trend Analysis - Provide feedback on incident trends and patterns as needed.

      4.3.3. Access to Training Resources - Assist in securing cost-effective training resources for partnership agreement participants.

      4.3.4. Interpretation of OSHA Standards - Clarify the intent of OSHA standards and resolve conflicts of interpretation with assistance from the Office of Construction Standards and OSHA Compliance Assistance.

      4.3.5. Compliance strategies - Provide input on compliance strategies as proposed by program participants.

      4.3.6 Employer Incentives – Extend as appropriate special recognition to partnership agreement employers that voluntarily improve their safety and health performance.

      4.3.7 Attendance at Safety and Health Meetings - OSHA representatives will periodically attend site safety and health meetings.
    4.5 Craft Labor’s Role

      4.5.1. EH&S Field Performance - Meet all project EH&S requirements relative to work assignments as a condition of employment.

      4.5.2. Safe Work on Demand - Refuse any work assignment that violates the project EH&S requirements.

      4.5.3. Monthly EH&S Meetings - Attend and participate in monthly meetings that are held by Barr & Barr, Inc.. Provide input on EH&S as related to specific trade/skill areas of expertise.

      4.5.4. Partnership Representation - Designate representative(s) to provide input in all partnership agreement initiatives.
5.0 Measurement and Evaluation of Performance
    5.1 Barr & Barr, Inc. will compile and track a monthly summary of contractor injury and illness performance statistics at the job site. This data will be compared to Barr & Barr, Inc. historical data, the historical data (if available) of the participating employers, and national data for comparison and evaluation.

    5.2 Barr & Barr, Inc. will collect documentation from contractors in order to ensure procedural performance of project requirements.

    5.3 At the end of each quarter, Barr & Barr, Inc., will compile and submit to OSHA a report that evaluates the partnership agreement's achievements and identify areas for continued improvement. Near misses are an integral part of the accident prevention program and will be evaluated by the safety and health team.

    5.4 At the end of this Partnership, OSHA and Barr & Barr, Inc. shall conduct a final review of the partnership through an inspection of the project similar to the inspection outlined in paragraph 5.3 above.
6.0 Communication of Results
    6.1 Barr & Barr, Inc. will publish a monthly status report to document partnership agreement status and progress. The signatories or their designated representative(s) will meet at least quarterly to review partnership agreement status and progress. This meeting will take place at the Syracuse Area OSHA Office.
7.0 Employee Involvement and Employee Rights
    7.1 This partnership agreement fully supports and recognizes the importance of employee participation in matters concerning safety and health in the workplace. As a vital component of an effective safety and health program, the ability of employees to exercise their rights, which are guaranteed under the OSH Act, will not be infringed. Employee involvement in the worksite safety and health program will be encouraged, including employee participation in safety and health program reviews, site inspections, employee safety and health training, accident investigations, and freedom to report hazards, including near misses. The signatory construction trade unions directly involved, or, effected by this partnership have been consulted and encouraged to suggest improvements and further enhancements of this partnership. All employee, trade organization, and union involvement in this Partnership will be documented by Barr & Barr, Inc.
8.0 Verification and OSHA Inspections
    8.1 Barr & Barr, Inc., shall exercise control over any recognized site safety and health hazard to eliminate the potential for injury or illness in accordance with this partnership agreement. Barr & Barr Inc., or its representatives, will conduct comprehensive safety and health reviews and audits. If any subcontractor, under the control and direction of Barr & Barr Inc., does not meet the terms of this partnership agreement, the subcontractor may be subject to traditional enforcement action by OSHA.

    8.2 Programmed Inspections – OSHA will not conduct a Programmed Inspection of a partnering subcontractor if OSHA has conducted a Verification Inspection, as described in Section 8.1.5 of this Partnership Agreement, within the twelve month period preceding the initiation of such an inspection. Should a Programmed Inspection, such as a National Emphasis Program (NEP) or a Local Emphasis Program (LEP), result in the initiation of a Programmed Inspection of Barr & Barr, Inc., and the employers engaged in this partnership, the inspection will focus on:

    1. The hazards identified as targets of the NEP or SEP;
    2. The hazards identified by this Partnership: falls, electrical, caught in/between, struck-by, and silica-related hazards.
    Hazards identified may result in the issuance of citations and penalties.

    8.3 Unprogrammed Inspections - Barr & Barr, Inc., and the employers engaged in this partnership recognize and accept that OSHA will fully investigate incidents involving employee deaths or the hospitalization of three or more employees, reports of imminent danger conditions, formal complaints and referrals. These inspections will be conducted outside the partnership in accordance with normal enforcement procedures and practices. Hazards identified may result in the issuance of citations and penalties.

    8.4 Complaint/Referral Investigations – OSHA agrees that a copy of each non-formal complaint/referral related to the work at the Project and filed with OSHA will be forwarded by fax, or by other means, to Barr & Barr’s project office. The name of the complainant will not be revealed. Barr & Barr, Inc. agrees to promptly investigate complaints, regardless of the employer involved, and provide OSHA with a written response within three days for non-formal complaints/referrals alleging a serious hazard, and within three days when an other-than-serious hazard is alleged.

    Failure to meet these timeframes will place the complaint/referral outside the scope of this Partnership and OSHA will respond as it would to any complaint of a similar nature.

    8.5 On-site Verification - In order to qualify for partnership, OSHA will conduct a verification inspection of the project pursuant to section 8, within 30 days of the signing of this agreement and every 6 months thereafter to reflect those new contractors who have arrived on site following previous verification inspections. This verification will determine Barr & Barr, Inc., and contractor compliance with the terms of this agreement. It will also include a comprehensive review of each onsite subcontractor’s Safety and Health program for its effectiveness in eliminating the four major construction hazards (falls, electrical, caught in/between and struck-by hazards), and a comprehensive review of the silicosis prevention program to ensure elimination of silica-related hazards. Serious hazards may result in the issuance of citations and penalties. Subcontractors who are determined, either by Barr & Barr, Inc., or OSHA, to be outside the aforementioned criteria for inclusion in this partnership agreement will be subject to traditional OSHA inspections and enforcement actions.

    8.6 Follow-up Inspections - If OSHA issues citations for serious hazards on any inspection conducted at this project during the tenure of this Partnership, OSHA may conduct a follow-up inspection to verify abatement.
9.0 Termination of Partnership Agreement

This agreement will terminate on July 01, 2008 which is 2 years from the date of the signing or may be extended dependant on the actual completion of the project. If any signatory of this agreement wishes to terminate their participation prior to the established termination date, written notice of the intent to withdraw must be provided to all other signatories.

If OSHA chooses to withdraw its participation in the partnership, the entire agreement is terminated. Any signatory party may also propose modification or amendment of the agreement.

For non-signatory participants of the strategic partnership, OSHA may terminate the participant’s involvement at any time with written notice. Additionally, the participant may withdraw their participation from the strategic partnership at any time with a written withdraw to OSHA.

10.0 Signatures

 
Occupational Safety and Health Administration    



 
Patricia K. Clark
Region 2 Regional Administrator
US Department of Labor/OSHA



 
Date
   



 
Christopher R Adams, CIH, CSP
Area Director, Syracuse Area Office
US Department of Labor/OSHA



 
Date
   


Barr & Barr, Inc.
     



 
Donald Barr
Vice President
Barr & Barr, Inc.



 
Date
   



 
Joseph X. Berry
Project Manager
Barr & Barr, Inc.



 
Date
   



 
James V. Manoli, CSP
Safety Director,
Barr & Barr, Inc. Building, Inc.



 
Date
   



 
Jennifer A Martin
Regional Safety Director
Barr & Barr, Inc.



 
Date



 
Richard Budnar P.E.
Superintendent
Barr & Barr, Inc.



 
Date


Maxim Construction Services
 

SRI Fire Sprinkler Corporation
 



 
Steve Slate
Safety Director
Maxim Construction Services



 
Date



 
John Deluca
Senior Project Manager
SRI Fire Sprinkler Corp



 
Date


AJAY Glass Company
 

Northland Associates, Inc
 



 
Steve Stathopolous
President
AJAY Glass Co.



 
Date



 
Bob Miller
Project Superintendent
Northland Associates



 
Date


Woodcock & Armani Mechanical
 

Island International Industries
 



 
Denys Thompson
President
Woodcock & Armani Mechanical



 
Date



 
Chris Chetti
Safety Officer
Island International Industries



 
Date


J & K Plumbing & Heating Company, Inc.
   



 
Mark Larson
Vice President
J & K Plumbing & Heating Company, Inc.



 
Date



 
Donna Snay
Safety Director
J & K Plumbing & Heating Company, Inc.



 
Date


Fast Trek Steel, Inc
 

Syracuse Merit Electric
 



 
George Colvin
President
Fast Trek Steel, Inc



 
Date



 
Bill Stanvick
Safety Coordinator
Syracuse Merit Electric



 
Date


Canatal Industries
     



 
Jacques Rodrigue
Project Manager
Canatal Industries



 
Date
   

Appendix A to Barr & Barr, Inc., Partnership (a guide to the performance of this partnership)

Goals, Strategies and Measurements

Goal # 1: Eliminate serious accidents, including four primary construction hazards (Falls, Electrocution, Struck By, and Caught In).

Strategy: Reduce the number of conditions that have potential to result in worker injury by:
  1. Providing 10 hr Construction Industry Safety Training to all Supervisory personal within 3 months of their starting work on this project.
  2. Providing 10 hr Construction Industry Safety Training to all non supervisory personal within three months of their starting work on this project.
  3. Abating hazards that are identified form the daily safety and health inspection of this worksite (see Barr & Barr, Inc., daily worksite inspection forms, appendix ? of Barr & Barr, Inc., Safety & Health Management Program)
Measurement:
  1. Documented Training records
  2. Documented Training records
  3. Documented daily site safety inspections
Note to Goal # 1: Supervisors and non supervisory employees who have completed the 10 hr Construction Industry training within the last five years meet the criteria of this goal.

Goal # 2: Zero Fatalities

Strategy: Barr & Barr, Inc., and all partners will strive through education and evaluation to make this a zero fatality worksite.

Measurement: At the end of each quarter, Barr & Barr, Inc., will compile and submit to OSHA a report that evaluates the partnerships agreement’s achievements and identify areas for continued improvement. Near misses are an integral part of the accident prevention program and will be evaluated by the safety and health team.


Goal # 3: Zero accidents and employees exposures involving trenches and excavations without adequate collapse protection.

Strategy: Provide a competent person to inspect and control all excavations at the work site.

Measurement: Zero collapse of excavations at the work site with employee exposure.


Goal # 4: No employees exposed to silica above OSHA’s General Industry Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL) without utilization of feasible engineering controls, administrative controls, and work practice controls and/or adequate respiratory protection.

Strategy: Examine all work areas and projects to determine the potential for silica exposure and implement feasible engineering, administrative, and work practice controls. Where warranted provide respiratory protection following OSHA’s standards for respiratory protection.

Measurement: Provide a comprehensive silicosis prevention program for this work site.

 
 
Back to Top Back to Top www.osha.gov www.dol.gov

Contact Us | Freedom of Information Act | Customer Survey
Privacy and Security Statement | Disclaimers
Occupational Safety & Health Administration
200 Constitution Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20210
  Page last updated: 01/24/2007