Technical Links >
Autobody >
TDI User Guidelines for Chemical Protective Clothing Selection
| DISCLAIMER |
This is not DOL or OSHA controlled material
and is provided here for reference only. We take no responsibility for the views, content
or accuracy of this information. |
Polyurethane Division
The Society of the Plastics Industry, Inc.
Technical Bulletin
July 1994 - AX178
PMDI User Guidelines for Chemical Protective Clothing Selection
Contents
Foreword
Importance of Industrial Hygiene
Selecting Personal Protective Clothing
Research Approach
Discussion Tables
Tables
Additional Information
Foreword
This technical bulletin presents guidelines for selecting the appropriate chemical
protective clothing for working with polymeric methylene diisocyanate (polymeric MDI or
PMDI) * and PMDI-based foam systems. This technical bulletin analyzes and
reviews performance characteristics, product availability, and costs for a variety of
commercially available gloves, coveralls, splash suits and other protective suits.
Importance of Industrial Hygiene
During the handling, processing and application of PMDI, potential exposure poses distinct
health and safety concerns. Contact with PMDI in vapor, liquid, or particulate form may
cause a range of adverse health effects, including irritation and/or sensitization to PMDI.
Short- or long-term exposure to PMDI can affect the skin, eyes and respiratory system.
Chronic dermal exposure can lead to skin irritation, skin sensitization, and may cause
respiratory sensitization.
Exposure guidelines have been established to help individuals avoid overexposure and
these adverse health effects. For details, see SPI Polyurethane Division Technical
Bulletin AX119, "MDI-Based Polyurethane Foam Systems: Guidelines for Safe Handling
and Disposal," and Technical Bulletin AX150, "Hyperreactivity and Other Health
Effects of Diisocyanates: Guidelines for Medical Personnel."
Selecting Personal Protective Clothing
Individuals handling chemicals need to understand and practice safe handling techniques
for PMDI and other chemicals that pose potential health hazards. This includes the wearing
of the appropriate protective clothing, including eye protection (face shield or chemical
worker's goggles), gloves, plus coveralls or lab aprons. This is essential to preventing
skin exposure in some jobs and is strongly recommended for most individuals who work with PMDI.
When selecting protective clothing, a variety of factors must be considered. These factors include:
- Chemical Resistance of Glove or Garment: To be effective, the protective
clothing must resist permeation and penetration by the chemical or chemicals being
handled. Use of disposable gloves and clothing is often preferred, because proper
decontamination of reusable items is often difficult.
- Specific Job Functions: The nature of the job being performed will greatly
influence the selection and features of protective clothing. For example, analyzing foam
samples in a laboratory may require light-duty gloves (<10 mils in thickness) that are
flexible and preserve manual dexterity; on the other hand, a maintenance project, such as
repairing a pump line, may require thicker gloves that are rugged and durable.
When the manual dexterity requirements of some jobs require the use of thin,
form-fitting gloves that offer limited amounts of protection time, use of such gloves is
acceptable if the gloves are changed with sufficient frequency. The
protection times listed in the tables are the maximum wearing times.
- Potential for Exposure: The degree of exposure risk for individual job
functions will help determine the degree of personal protection required and the
appropriate clothing selected. For instance, work conducted in a laboratory environment,
where the potential for exposure is limited to a localized area, may only require gloves
and either a lab apron or lab coat, in addition to eye protection. On the other hand, a
project that presents a greater risk for an acute exposure, such as loading and unloading
tank cars, may require the use of hooded coveralls, boots and gloves to ensure adequate
protection.
- Duration of Exposure: The length of time that an individual is working or
handling PMDI will influence the type of protective clothing selected. When working with
PMDI for extended time periods, protective clothing that offers the greatest level of
chemical resistance is recommended.
The PMDI protection times referred to in this technical bulletin are based on the time
required for PMDI to permeate or make its way through the chemical protective glove or
garment material, and are the maximum use times. It is important for the wearer to
understand the need to change gloves and garments often enough to avoid exceeding the
listed protection times and to prevent contacting PMDI. For example if a job requires the
use of thin, flexible gloves with a 30 minute protection time, then the wearer should
change gloves within 30 minutes from initial contact with PMDI.
- Cost and Market Availability: When selecting protective clothing, product costs
and market availability are important considerations. The tables indicate which products
are available in the Americas, Europe, and Asia Pacific. The tables also provide typical
prices, in U.S. dollars, for case lot quantities. These prices can be used to assess
relative cost of various products, but actual prices will vary considerably because most
chemical protective clothing is sold through independent distributors.
In addition to these factors, individual work habits, industrial hygiene practices and
personal experiences will influence decisions made when selecting protective clothing.
Research Approach
The International Isocyanates Institute (III) sponsored a study whereby Texas Research
Institute evaluated materials from more than 50 items of chemical protective clothing
– 35 gloves of 10 different material types and 17 suits of 14 different material
types – to determine the degree of resistance to permeation by PMDI that each garment
offers.
The III research measured the length of time it took PMDI to permeate through the
protective clothing material under conditions of continuous contact and complete surface
coverage with PMDI.
The research did not address how glove and garment protection for PMDI users may be
affected by solvents; nor did the research evaluate how effectively the gloves and
garments protect workers against solvent exposures. It should be noted that some solvents,
such as methylene chloride, are expected to quickly (<0.25 hour) permeate most of the
protective clothing listed in the tables. PMDI may be carried through the garment with the
solvent.
Discussion of Tables
Separate tables for gloves and body protective clothing are organized by glove or garment
type, then within type are arranged by decreasing protection time. The tables also include
the following information for each item: trade name, manufacturer, availability,
approximate cost, thickness, and durability.
although a large number of chemical protective gloves and garments were tested, this
technical bulletin is not intended to be a comprehensive review of every piece of
protective clothing currently available. Other gloves and garments not included in this
study may provide equivalent protection.
Individuals who work with PMDI should keep themselves informed of new protective
clothing developments and consult their protective clothing suppliers and manufacturers.
| Protective Gloves for Polymeric MDI (PMDI) by type (light, medium, heavy
duty); within type, by protection time |
| Glove Type |
Material |
Thickness (mil) |
Durability* |
Dexterity* |
Typical Case Lot Cost (US$) |
PMDI Protection Time (hours) |
Manufacturer /Distributor |
Trade Name |
Model No. |
Available |
| Heavy Duty |
Neoprene |
38.5 |
Medium |
Medium |
4.04 |
>8.0 |
Ansell Edmont |
Scorpio |
8-352 |
Americas Europe |
| Heavy Duty |
Neoprene |
72.0 |
High |
Low |
5.63 |
>8.0 |
Ansell Edmont |
Neox |
9-924 |
Americas Europe |
| Heavy Duty |
Butyl |
29.0 |
High |
Low |
25.00 |
>8.0 |
Kachele-Cama Latex (KCL) |
Butojet (NAPA) |
898 |
Europe |
| Heavy Duty |
Neoprene |
57.0 |
High |
Low |
15.83 |
>8.0 |
Towa Corp. |
Neo-G |
950 |
Asia Pacific |
| Heavy Duty |
PVC |
48.5 |
High |
Medium |
2.25 |
>8.0 |
North |
Hygesan |
|
Europe |
| Heavy Duty |
PVC |
30.5 |
High |
Medium |
8.83 |
>8.0 |
Showa-Kako |
Vinylove |
212 |
Asia Pacific |
| Heavy Duty |
Chlorosul- fonated PE |
27.0 |
High |
Medium |
36.17 |
>8.0 |
Daiua-Gumo |
Benkei |
95 |
Asia Pacific |
| Heavy Duty |
Nitrile |
42.0 |
High |
Medium |
4.08 |
>8.0 |
Best |
Ultraflex |
21R |
Americas Europe |
| Heavy Duty |
PVC |
51.0 |
High |
Low |
2.26 |
>8.0 |
Best |
Black Knight |
7712R |
Americas Europe |
|
| Heavy Duty |
Nitrile |
30.5 |
High |
Medium |
5.33 |
>8.0 |
S.T. Chemical |
|
600 |
Asia Pacific |
| Heavy Duty |
Chloroprene Rubber |
32.0 |
Medium |
Medium |
3.50 |
6.5 |
Kachele-Cama Latex (KCL) |
Camapren Latex |
720 |
Europe |
| Heavy Duty |
PVC |
57.0 |
High |
Low |
2.34 |
6.5 |
Jomac |
|
8112 |
Americas |
| Heavy Duty |
PVC |
39.0 |
High |
Low |
2.26 |
3.5 |
Jomac |
|
7112 |
Americas |
| Heavy Duty |
Nitrile - Modified |
28.0 |
High |
Low |
8.33 |
1.5 |
Sugita |
Ryulon |
C50 |
Asia Pacific |
| Glove Type |
Material |
Thickness (mil) |
Durability* |
Dexterity* |
Typical Case Lot Cost (US$) |
PMDI Protection Time (hours) |
Manufacturer /Distributor |
Trade Name |
Model No. |
Available |
| Medium duty |
Polyurethane |
14.5 |
High |
Medium |
26.67 |
>8.0 |
Sanko Chemical |
Kemitex |
KMT |
Asia Pacific |
| Medium duty |
Nitrile |
17.0 |
Low |
High |
2.00 |
>8.0 |
Lab Safety Supply |
|
5677 |
Americas |
| Medium duty |
Butyl |
11.5 |
Low |
High |
14.35 |
>8.0 |
North |
|
B-131 |
Americas Europe |
| Medium duty |
Laminated PE/EVAL |
2.0 |
Medium |
Medium |
3.85 |
>8.0 |
Safety4 (Ansell Edmont) |
4H |
(87400) |
Americas Europe |
| Medium duty |
Nitrile |
18.0 |
High |
Low |
1.70 |
>8.0 |
Ansell Edmont |
Solvex |
37-675 |
Europe |
| Medium duty |
Fluorinated Rubber |
13.5 |
Medium |
Medium |
62.50 |
>8.0 |
Hanaki-Gomu |
Hanalove |
617-X |
Asia Pacific |
| Medium duty |
Butyl |
17.5 |
Medium |
Medium |
17.25 |
>8.0 |
North |
|
B-161 |
Americas Europe |
| Medium duty |
Laminated PE/EVAL |
4.0 |
Medium |
Medium |
2.75 |
>8.0 |
North |
SilverShield |
(7094) |
Americas Europe |
| Medium duty |
Nitrile |
18.5 |
Medium |
Medium |
1.83 |
>8.0 |
Pioneer |
Stansolv |
AF-18 |
Americas |
| Medium duty |
Natural Rubber |
11.0 |
Low |
High |
0.70 |
1.5-2.0 |
Pioneer |
|
L118 |
Americas |
| Medium duty |
Natural Rubber |
20.0 |
Medium |
Medium |
0.59 |
1.5 |
Ansell Edmont |
|
392 |
Americas Europe |
| Medium duty |
Natural Rubber |
18.0 |
Low |
High |
1.75 |
1.5 |
Marigold |
|
326 Y |
Americas Europe |
| Medium duty |
Silicone Rubber |
21.0 |
Medium |
Medium |
58.33 |
1.0 |
Daiya-Gomu |
Dialove |
H203 |
Asia Pacific |
| Glove Type |
Material |
Thickness (mil) |
Durability* |
Dexterity* |
Typical Case Lot Cost (US$) |
PMDI Protection Time (hours) |
Manufacturer /Distributor |
Trade Name |
Model No. |
Available |
| Light duty |
Nitrile |
6.0 |
Low |
High |
0.74 |
>8.0 |
Best |
N-Dex |
9005 |
Americas |
| Light duty |
Nitrile |
8.5 |
Low |
High |
0.30 |
>8.0 |
Best |
N-Dex |
7005 |
Americas |
| Light duty |
PVC |
9.0 |
|
|
0.85 |
2.0 |
Pioneer |
Pylox |
212 (V-10) |
Americas |
| Light duty |
Polyethylene |
1.0 |
Low |
Medium |
0.07 |
1.5 |
Unknown |
|
Disposable |
Europe |
| Light duty |
Polyethylene |
1.0 |
Low |
Medium |
0.06 |
1.5 |
Seiko |
Disposable HDPE |
Standard |
Asia Pacific |
| Light duty |
Polyethylene |
0.5 |
Low |
Medium |
0.07 |
1.5 |
Seiko |
Disposable LDPE |
Strong A |
Asia Pacific |
| Light duty |
Polyethylene |
1.5 |
Low |
Medium |
0.07 |
1.0 |
Ansell Edmont |
|
35-112 |
Americas Europe |
| Light duty |
Natural Rubber |
7.0 |
Low |
High |
1.58 |
0.5 |
Sanko Chemical |
Surgical glove |
7.5 |
Asia Pacific |
| Light duty |
Natural Rubber |
5.0 |
Low |
High |
0.19 |
0.25 |
Johnson & Johnson |
Microtouch |
(1) |
Americas |
| Light duty |
Natural Rubber |
7.0 |
Low |
High |
0.16 |
<0.25 |
Best |
Dermathin |
1005 |
Americas |
| *
Based on subjective evaluation - information provided as a guideline only |
| Body Protective
clothing for Polymeric MDI (PMDI) by garment type; within type, by protection time |
| Clothing Type |
Material |
Thickness (mil) |
Durability* |
Typical Case Lot Cost (US$) |
PMDI Protection Time (hours) |
Manufacturer /Distributor |
Trade Name |
Model No. |
Available |
| Coverall (Disposable) |
Laminated |
9.0 |
High |
42.05 |
>8.0 |
Chemron |
Chemrel |
|
Americas Europe |
| Coverall (Disposable) |
Nonwoven |
7.0 |
Medium |
15.05 |
>8.0 |
DuPont |
Tyvek /Saranex23P |
|
Americas Europe Asia Pacific |
| Coverall (Disposable) |
Laminated |
10.0 |
High |
30.10 |
>8.0 |
Chemron |
Chemtuff |
|
Americas Europe |
| Coverall (Disposable) |
Laminated |
14.0 |
High |
49.40 |
>8.0 |
DuPont |
Barricade |
|
Americas Europe Asia Pacific |
| Coverall (Disposable) |
Nonwoven |
6.0 |
Low |
8.90 |
>8.0 |
DuPont |
Tyvek QC (PE) |
|
Americas Europe Asia Pacific |
| Coverall (Disposable) |
Laminated |
15.0 |
High |
46.55 |
>8.0 |
Kappler |
CPF III |
|
Americas |
| Coverall (Disposable) |
Nonwoven |
20.0 |
Low |
40.00 |
<0.25 |
Kimberly Clark (Durafab) |
Comfort Gard III |
|
Americas |
| Coverall (Disposable) |
Nonwoven |
5.0 |
Low |
4.80 |
<0.25 |
DuPont |
Tyvek |
|
Americas Europe Asia Pacific |
| Coverall (Disposable) |
Nonwoven |
13.0 |
Low |
7.50 |
<0.25 |
Kimberly Clark |
Kleen Guard EP |
|
Americas Europe |
| Clothing Type |
Material |
Thickness (mil) |
Durability* |
Typical Case Lot Cost (US$) |
PMDI Protection Time (hours) |
Manufacturer /Distributor |
Trade Name |
Model No. |
Available |
| Splash Suit Level (B) |
Laminated |
14.0 |
High |
170.95 |
>8.0 |
Lifeguard |
Responder |
|
Americas |
| Splash Suit |
PVC |
11.0 |
High |
35.00 |
>8.0 |
River City |
|
300J |
Americas |
| Splash Suit |
PVC |
11.0 |
High |
32.05 |
>8.0 |
MSA |
Wearwolf |
695405 |
Americas |
| Splash Suit |
Polyurethane |
8.0 |
Low |
45.00 |
>8.0 |
Rainfair |
|
1100-2194 |
Americas |
| Splash Suit |
Neoprene |
7.0 |
High |
71.59 |
>8.0 |
Rainfair |
Nyloguard |
1100-3890 |
Americas |
| Splash Suit |
PVC |
10.0 |
High |
30.00 |
7.5 to >8.0 |
Neese Rubber Co. |
|
35 |
Americas |
| * Based on
subjective assessment - information provided as a guideline only |
PRINCIPLES OF PROTECTIVE CLOTHING SELECTION
- Item needs to be suitable for the job.
- Item should offer a protection time that exceeds potential exposure times.
- Item should be replaced before protection time is exceeded.
- Disposable items are often preferable to reusable ones, because of
contamination/decontamination concerns.
Additional Information
For additional information on PMDI protective clothing, safe handling, and disposal,
consult the following sources:
- "Guidelines for the Selection of Chemical Protective
Clothing," American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists, 6500 Glenway
Avenue, Building D-7, Cincinnati, Ohio 45211-4438
- Technical Data Sheets (TDS) and current Material Safety
Data Sheets (MSDS) for polymethylene polyphenyl isocyanates (PMDI) available from the
supplier.
- "Using Flexible Polyurethane Foams Safely,"
(Technical Bulletin AX115) Polyurethane Division, The Society of the Plastics Industry,
Inc., 355 Lexington Avenue, New York, New York 10017
- "Hyperreactivity and Other Health Effects of
Diisocyanates: Guidelines for Medical Personnel" (Technical Bulletin AX150),
Polyurethane Division, The Society of the Plastics Industry, Inc., 355 Lexington
Avenue, New York, New York 10017
- MDI-Based Polyurethane Foam Systems: Guidelines for Safe
Handling and Disposal" (Technical Bulletin AX119), Polyurethane Division, The Society
of the Plastics Industry, Inc., 355 Lexington Avenue, New York, New York 10017
- "Guidelines for the Disposal of Empty Diisocyanate
Containers," (Technical Bulletin AX151) Polyurethane Division, The Society of the
Plastics Industry, Inc., 355 Lexington Avenue, New York, New York 10017
*In the United States, MDI is the usual abbreviation for
"pure" (as opposed to modified or polymeric) diphenylmethane diisocyanate, or
methylene diphenyl diisocyanate, or methylene bis (p-phenyl isocyanate) or
diisocyanatodiphenylmethane. However, certain U.S. and most foreign manufacturers and end
users also use "MDI" to refer to the undistilled mixture of 4,4'-diphenylmethane
diisocyanate and to higher molecular weight fractions. Other synonyms for MDI are
iscoyanic acid: p,p'-methylene diphenyl diester; iscoyanic acid: methylene di-p-phenylene
ester; and 1,1'-methylene bis (isocyanato benzene). There also are "polymeric"
forms of MDI, which typically consist of 30-70 percent diphenyl methane diisocyanate and
the balance in higher molecular weight fractions. The CAS Number for polymeric MDI is
9016-87-9.
|