US Dept of Labor

Occupational Safety & Health AdministrationWe Can Help

  • Home
  • Workers
  • Regulations
  • Enforcement
  • Data & Statistics
  • Training
  • Publications
  • Newsroom
  • Regulations (Standards - 29 CFR) - Table of Contents
    • Part Number: 1990
    • Part Title: Identification, Classification, and Regulation of Carcinogens
    • Standard Number: 1990.144
    • Title: Criteria for consideration of arguments on certain issues.
    • GPO Source: e-CFR

    Arguments on the following issues will be considered by the Secretary in identifying or classifying any substance pursuant to this part, if evidence for the specific substance subject to the rulemaking conforms to the following criteria. Such arguments and evidence will be evaluated based upon scientific and policy judgments.

    1990.144(a)

    Non-positive results obtained in human epidemiologic studies. Non-positive results obtained in human epidemiologic studies regarding the substance subject to the rulemaking or to a similar or closely related substance will be considered by the Secretary only if they meet the following criteria:

       Criteria (i) The epidemiologic study involved at least 20 years'
     exposure of a group of subjects to the substance and at least 30 years
     observation of the subjects after initial exposure;
       (ii) Documented reasons are provided for predicting the site(s) at
     which the substance would induce cancer if it were carcinogenic in
     humans; and
       (iii) The group of exposed subjects was large enough for an increase
     in cancer incidence of 50% above that in unexposed controls to have been
     detected at any of the predicted sites.
    
    

    Arguments that non-positive results obtained in human epidemiologic studies should be used to establish numerical upper limits on potential risks to humans exposed to specific levels of a substance will be considered only if criteria (i) and (ii) are met and, in addition:

       (iv) Specific data on the level of exposure of the group of workers
     are provided, based either on direct measurements made periodically
     throughout the period of exposure, or upon other data which provide
     reliable evidence of the magnitude of exposure.
    
    

    1990.144(b)

    Tumors induced at site of administration. Arguments that tumors at the site of administration should not be considered will be considered only if:

    [i] The route of administration is not oral, respiratory or dermal; and

    [ii] Evidence is provided which establishes that induction of local tumors is related to the physical configuration or formulation of the material administered (e.g., crystalline form or dimensions of a solid material, or matrix of an impregnated implant) and that tumors are not induced when the same material is administered in a different configuration or formula.

    1990.144(c)

    Metabolic differences. Arguments that differences in metabolic profiles can be used to demonstrate that a chemical found positive in an experimental study in a mammalian species would pose no potential carcinogenic risk to exposed workers will be considered by the Secretary only if the evidence presented for the specific substance subject to the rulemaking meets the following criteria:

       Criteria. (i) A complete metabolic profile, including identities of
     trace metabolites, is presented for the experimental animal species;
       (ii) A complete metabolic profile, including identities of trace
     metabolites, is available for a human population group representative of
     those who are occupationally exposed;
       (iii) Documented evidence is provided for ascribing the carcinogenic
     activity of the substance in the test animal species to metabolite(s)
     produced only in that species and not in humans; and
       (iv) Documented evidence is provided to show that other metabolites
     produced also in humans have been adequately tested and have not been
     shown to be carcinogenic.
    
    

    1990.144(d)

    Use of high doses in animal testing. Arguments that positive results obtained in carcinogenesis bioassays with experimental animals subjected to high doses of a substance are not relevant to potential carcinogenic risks to exposed workers will be considered by the Secretary only if the evidence for the specific substance subject to the rulemaking meets the following criteria:

       Criteria. (i) Documented evidence is presented to show that the
     substance in question is metabolized by the experimental animal species
     exposed at the dose levels used in the bioassay(s) to metabolic products
     which include one or more that are not produced in the same species at
     lower doses.
       (ii) Documented evidence is presented to show that the metabolite(s)
     produced only at high doses in the experimental animal species are the
     ultimate carcinogen(s) and that the metabolites produced at low doses
     are not also carcinogenic; and
       (iii) Documented evidence is presented to show that the metabolite(s)
     produced only at high doses in the experimental animal species are not
     produced in humans exposed to low doses.
    
    

    ..1990.144(e)

    1990.144(e)

    Benign tumors. The Secretary will consider evidence that the substance subject to the rulemaking proceeding is capable only of inducing benign tumors in humans or experimental animals provided that the evidence for the specific substance meets the following criteria:

       Criteria. (i) Data are available from at least two well-conducted
     bioassays in each of two species of mammals (or from equivalent evidence
     in more than two species);
       (ii) Each of the bioassays to be considered has been conducted for the
     full lifetime of the experimental animals;
       (iii) The relevant tissue slides are made available to OSHA or its
     designee and the diagnoses of the tumors as benign are made by at least
     one qualified pathologist who has personally examined each of the slides
     and who provides specific diagnostic criteria and descriptions; and
       (iv) All of the induced tumors must be shown to belong to a type which
     is known not to progress to malignancy or to be at a benign stage when
     observed. In the latter case, data must be presented to show that
     multiple sections of the affected organ(s) were adequately examined to
     search for invasion of the tumor cells into adjacent tissue, and that
     multiple sections of other organs were adequately examined to search for
     tumor metastases.
    
    

    1990.144(f)

    Indirect mechanisms. The Secretary will consider evidence that positive results obtained in a carcinogenesis bioassay with experimental animals are not relevant to a determination of a carcinogenic risk to exposed workers, if the evidence demonstrates that the mechanism by which the observed tumor incidence is effected is indirect and would not occur if humans were exposed. As examples, evidence will be considered that a substance causes a carcinogenic effect by augmenting caloric intake or that the carcinogenic effect from exposure to a substance is demonstrated to be the result of the presence of a carcinogenic virus and it is demonstrated that, in either case, the effect would not take place in the absence of the particular carcinogenic virus or the augmented caloric intake.

    [45 FR 5282, Jan. 22, 1980, as amended at 46 FR 5881, Jan. 21, 1981]


    Next Standard (1990.145)

    Regulations (Standards - 29 CFR) - Table of Contents

Thank You for Visiting Our Website

You are exiting the Department of Labor's Web server.

The Department of Labor does not endorse, takes no responsibility for, and exercises no control over the linked organization or its views, or contents, nor does it vouch for the accuracy or accessibility of the information contained on the destination server. The Department of Labor also cannot authorize the use of copyrighted materials contained in linked Web sites. Users must request such authorization from the sponsor of the linked Web site. Thank you for visiting our site. Please click the button below to continue.

Close