Regulations (Preambles to Final Rules) - Table of Contents|
| Record Type:||Nationally Recognized Testing Laboratories-Fees|
| Title:||Section 3 - III. Explanation of Final Rule|
III. Explanation of Final Rule
A. Establishment of Fees
OSHA is modifying 29 CFR 1910.7 to add a new paragraph "(f) Fees" related to the assessment and payment of fees for certain services rendered to NRTLs and NRTL applicants. This new paragraph provides the general framework that OSHA will use to calculate, charge, and collect the fees. OSHA will provide the specific details for calculating, charging, and collecting the fees through appropriate OSHA Program Directives, which will be published on the OSHA web site, consistent with the framework laid out in this final rule.
1. Obligation To Pay and Fee Assessment
The first part of paragraph (f) reads as follows:
(1) Each applicant for NRTL recognition and each NRTL must pay fees for services provided by OSHA. OSHA will assess fees for the following services:
(i) Processing of applications for initial recognition, expansion of recognition, or renewal of recognition, including on- site reviews; review and evaluation of the applications; and preparation of reports, evaluations and Federal Register notices; and
(ii) Audits of sites.
Organizations seeking OSHA recognition (i.e., NRTL applicants) and organizations that OSHA has recognized as NRTLs must pay fees for the specific services that OSHA provides to them. The services for which the Agency will charge fees are: (1) processing of applications for initial recognition, expansion of recognition, or renewal of recognition, and (2) audits, which are post-recognition on-site or office reviews. The activities involved in providing these services are described in more detail later.
Typically, OSHA annually audits the testing sites it has recognized for an NRTL. However, if an NRTL has appropriate controls in place, OSHA allows it to use non-recognized sites, such as testing sites of other laboratories or even manufacturers, to conduct testing or other activities necessary for certifying products. OSHA may also need to audit such non-recognized sites to determine whether the NRTL or the site is properly controlling the NRTL-related activities. For example, OSHA may audit a manufacturer to determine how well it controls the NRTL's certification mark or maintains production or quality controls. NRTLs must also pay for these "special" audits when required and will be billed accordingly.
2. Fee Calculation
The second part of paragraph (f) reads as follows:
(2) The fee schedule established by OSHA reflects the cost of performing the activities for each service listed in paragraph (f)(1) of this section. OSHA calculates the fees based on either the average or actual time required to perform the work necessary; the staff costs per hour (which include wages, fringe benefits, and expenses other than travel for personnel that perform or administer the activities covered by the fees); and the average or actual costs for travel when on-site reviews are involved. The formula for the fee calculation is as follows:
Activity Fee = [Average (or Actual) Hours to Complete the Activity x Staff Costs per Hour] + Average (or Actual) Travel Costs
Each activity performed by OSHA accomplishes a particular phase of the service the Agency provides to the recipients (i.e., NRTLs or NRTL applicants). Currently, these activities are as follows:
-- Review of initial, expansion, and renewal applications;
-- On-site assessment per person, per site -- first day, and per person, per site -- each additional day;
-- Review and evaluation (per standard) -- initial and expansion applications;
-- Final report/Federal Register notice -- initial and expansion or renewal applications; and
-- On-site audit (per person, per site) and office audit (per site).
The fees that the Agency is initially establishing are shown in the Fee Schedule (Table A in section VI of this preamble). This schedule is somewhat different from the one we published in the NPRM. We have made changes as a result of our decision, as explained in section II of this preamble, to bill NRTLs for audits and for certain assessments after we perform them. We had proposed in the NPRM (64 FR 45105) to pre-bill the NRTLs for these activities. We further explained that we would bill or refund to NRTLs the difference between any pre-paid fee amounts and the "actual costs" for an assessment and or audit. Since we have decided not to pre-bill for these activities, we have changed the fee schedule to clearly reflect this approach. The fee schedule now contains two types of fees: flat fees and variable fees.
The "flat fees" are calculated by multiplying the average estimated time to perform the work by the equivalent staff cost per hour, and adding the average travel costs for any assessment we must perform for an application for initial recognition. Use of the average time spent on each activity simplifies the accounting for the NRTL and for OSHA since the recordkeeping time and associated costs are reduced. The variable fees are based on the "actual costs,", i.e., actual staff time and travel costs to the government. These are calculated by multiplying the equivalent staff cost by the actual number of days or fractional days that staff spend in performing the on-site activity, and adding actual staff travel costs, using government rates where possible. In section V of this preamble, we show how we derived the equivalent staff cost per hour (Figure 1) and provide details on the costs and calculation for the fees.
As indicated above, we will bill applicants or NRTLs for the "actual costs" of an assessment and audit after we perform these activities. However, as we proposed in the NPRM (64 FR 45106) and now adopt in this final rule, applicants seeking initial recognition must still pay for an assessment in advance, i.e., at time of application, using the amount in the fee schedule. After we perform the assessment, OSHA will send them a bill or refund (i.e, credit their account) for the difference that reflects the "actual costs". We have added appropriate information to the fee schedule to clearly show the nature of the assessment fee for a new applicant.
3. Annual Review of Fee Schedule and Issuance
The third part of paragraph (f) reads as follows:
(3)(i) OSHA will review costs annually and will propose a revised fee schedule, if warranted. In its review, OSHA will apply the formula established in paragraph (f)(2) of this section to the current estimated costs for the NRTL Program. If a change is warranted, OSHA will follow the implementation table in paragraph (f)(4) of this section. (ii) OSHA will publish all fee schedules in the Federal Register. Once published, a fee schedule remains in effect until it is superseded by a new fee schedule. Any member of the public may request a change to the fees included in the current fee schedule. Such a request must include appropriate documentation in support of the suggested change. OSHA will consider such requests during its annual review of the fee schedule.
The first Fee Schedule, set forth in section VI of this preamble, will remain in effect until it is superseded by a revised schedule. OSHA will annually review the costs to the Government of providing the services to determine whether any changes to the fees are needed. In addition, as part of this annual review, OSHA will consider requests for changes to the fee schedule that it receives from the public. If OSHA believes that changes may be needed, we will publish a notice to provide the NRTLs and other members of the public an opportunity to comment on such changes. The Agency will follow the implementation table shown in paragraph (f)(4) of this rule. We will publish all subsequent fee schedules in the Federal Register and post them on the OSHA web site.
4. Fee Implementation
The fourth part of paragraph (f) reads as follows:
(4) OSHA will implement fee assessment, collection, and payment as follows:
|Approximate dates||Action required|
|I. Annual Review of Fee Schedule|
|November 1||OSHA will publish any proposed new Fee Schedule in the Federal Register, if OSHA determines changes in the schedule are warranted|
|November 16||Comments due on the proposed new Fee Schedule|
|December 15||OSHA will publish the final Fee Schedule in the Federal Register, making it effective|
|II. Application Processing Fees|
|Time of application||Applicant must pay the applicable fees shown in the Fee Schedule when submitting the application; OSHA will not begin processing until fees are received|
|Publication of preliminary notice||Applicant must pay remainder of fees; OSHA cancels application if fees are not paid when due|
|III. Audit Fees|
|After audit performed||OSHA will bill each existing NRTL for the audit fees in effect at the time of audit, but will reflect actual travel costs and staff time in the bill|
|30 days after bill date||NRTLs must pay audit fees; OSHA will assess late fee if audit fees are not paid|
|45 days after bill date||OSHA will send a letter to the NRTL requesting immediate payment of the audit fees and late fee|
|60 days after bill date||OSHA will publish a notice in the Federal Register announcing its intent to revoke recognition for NRTLs that have not paid these audit fees|
One significant change has been made to the table as a result of comments from ACIL (Ex. 8-3). Rather than billing each NRTL at the beginning of the year as proposed (64 FR 45105), we will bill them after an audit is conducted. Failure to pay the bill in a timely fashion may lead to revocation of recognition.
With regard to the other items in the schedule, OSHA needs approximately 30 days after the close of the government fiscal year (GFY) on September 30th, to obtain and review data for its annual review of the fee schedule. If a change in the schedule is necessary, OSHA will publish a proposed revision around November 1st, including an analysis of the changes. The period for comments will be no less than 15 calendar days. Approximately 30 days thereafter, OSHA will officially issue the new fee schedule in the Federal Register.
After we have audited an NRTL, we will bill that NRTL for the appropriate audit fee shown in the fee schedule in effect at the time the audit is performed. This bill will reflect actual travel costs and staff time for the audit. OSHA anticipates that most of the bills will be for on-site audits, rather than office audits. OSHA will automatically assess the NRTL the late fee, shown in the fee schedule, if the Agency does not fully receive the amount billed within 30 days. Fifteen days thereafter, if payment has not been received, OSHA will send a letter notifying the NRTL of the failure to pay the fees for the audit and requesting immediate payment, including a late fee. If the NRTL fails to fully pay those fees within 15 days of the issuance of the letter, OSHA will publish a notice in the Federal Register announcing its intent to revoke the NRTL's recognition. OSHA will then proceed with permanent revocation of the NRTL's recognition, which includes publication of a second notice formally revoking recognition.
In revoking recognition due to non-payment of fees, OSHA will follow the procedures described in this paragraph and not those under II.E of Appendix A to 29 CFR 1910.7. The Agency may consider reinstating an organization's recognition if it provides an explanation for non-payment that is acceptable to OSHA and it pays all fees that are due. We will address such a reinstatement option in the directive mentioned in paragraph (f)(5) below.
OSHA will bill the NRTL separately for additional audits of a site or for any "special" audits, and will bill applicants separately for any additional or special assessment that it must perform in connection with an application. OSHA will bill the NRTL or applicant for these fees after these audits or assessments and will follow the same collection process as described above.
5. Details for Payment
The fifth and last part of paragraph (f) reads as follows:
(5) OSHA will provide details about how to pay the fees through appropriate OSHA Program Directives, which will be available on the OSHA web site.
For application processing, OSHA will bill the NRTL applicant or NRTL for the balance of fees due, including the "actual costs" for any assessment, at the time we publish the preliminary notice to announce the application. As previously explained, publication of this notice occurs after we have completed any assessment for processing an application. For new applicants, the bill will reflect a refund (i.e., a credit) if the amount pre-paid exceeds the "actual costs" for the assessment. For expansion and renewal applications, the bill to the NRTL will include the fees for any assessment that we performed. For audits, we will also bill the NRTL after completion of the audit. For application processing and audits, any fees that are not paid when due will result in cancellation of application or revocation of recognition, as appropriate. OSHA will follow the same collection process for applications as that described for audits in paragraph (f)(4).
The instructions that accompany a fee schedule will include appropriate details about fee payments. OSHA will require payment of all fees in U.S. dollars by certified check or money order drawn on a U.S.-based institution or organization, but may include additional payment terms in these instructions. The Agency may consider other modes or methods for payment in these instructions.
The fees established by this final rule go into effect on October 1, 2000. Fees must be submitted for any application (whether for initial recognition, or expansion or renewal of recognition) postmarked on or after the effective date of the Fee Schedule shown in section VI of this preamble. Also, any application pending on October 1, 2000, will be subject to the fees for activities that OSHA has not yet begun as of that date. OSHA will bill applicants accordingly. However, since delays in processing may have occurred through no fault of an applicant, OSHA will review the circumstances surrounding all applications that are pending on October 1, 2000, to determine whether some fees should be waived.
B. Reduction of Public Comment Period
OSHA is amending provisions in Appendix A to 29 CFR 1910.7 to reduce the 60-day comment period currently required for the "preliminary" Federal Register notices. "Preliminary" refers to the first of the two notices that OSHA must publish to initially recognize an organization as an NRTL, or to expand or renew an NRTL's recognition. The notice announces OSHA's "preliminary finding" on an initial, expansion, or renewal application. The amended provisions of Appendix A will now provide a 30-day comment period for notices on applications for initial recognitions, and a 15-day comment period for notices on applications for expansion or renewal of recognition. The 30-day period for initial applications is consistent with that provided for some other notices published by the Agency. The shorter 15-day period reflects the nature and scope of OSHA's evaluation of expansion and renewal requests. Based on our experience, OSHA believes that such requests will present few issues. However, anyone who believes that the NRTL's request affects them but needs more time may request an extension of time to comment.
As pointed out in the proposal (64 FR 45107), in recent years, OSHA has received few or no comments on the preliminary notices. The comment periods add significantly to the amount of time required to process an application. Thus OSHA proposed to reduce the time periods required. ACIL (Ex. 8-3) recognized that this would reduce overall processing time. No comments were received objecting to this change.
NRTLs routinely adopt new test standards for the products that are within their testing and certification capability. Many of the new test standards are simply new revisions that supersede those for which OSHA has already recognized the NRTL. As a result, the NRTL must often apply to OSHA to "expand" its recognition to enable it to use the new test standards. While the NRTL may "expand" its recognition primarily to attain or maintain an economic benefit, timely recognition of the new test standards for the NRTL could also enhance safety in the workplace. The shorter periods will speed up approval of those expansions.
Federal Register notices are currently accessible to the public through the Office of the Federal Register web site on the day they are published. Reviewers of the notice can always request an extension of the comment period if they need more time for presenting any comments. OSHA will include a statement regarding such extensions in the preliminary notices. Given the rapid telecommunication (e.g., Internet, electronic mail, fax) capabilities that now exist throughout the world, comments or requests for an extension of the comment period can be filed in much less time than 60 days. OSHA will generally grant an extension but will limit it to 15 days, unless the requester justifies a longer period. We may deny a request for extension if it is frivolous or otherwise unwarranted.
[65 FR 46803, July 31, 2000]
|Regulations (Preambles to Final Rules) - Table of Contents|