Department of Labor Seal photos representing the workforce - digital imagery© copyright 2001 photodisc, inc.
Department of Labor Seal www.osha.gov    [skip navigational links] Search    Advanced Search | A-Z Index
Safety and Health Topics > Mineral Processing Dust Control > Reducing Dust Exposure
 
IC 9148 Bureau of Mines Information Circular/1987

Reducing Dust Exposure of Workers During Bag Stacking
in Enclosed Vehicles
 
By Andrew B. Cecala1, Anthony Cavelli2, and Edward D. Thimons3

U.S. Dept. of Interior logo

UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
Donald Paul Hodel, Secretary

Bureau of Mines logo

BUREAU OF MINES
David S. Brown, Acting Director
1Mining engineer.
2Mining engineer technician.
3Supervisory physical scientist.
Pittsburgh Research Center, Bureau of Mines, Pittsburgh, PA

 
CONTENTS

Abstract
Introduction 
Laboratory-scale testing
Laboratory-scale results 
Field testing
Discussion
Cost considerations
Conclusions
Appendix.--Curtain evaluation

ILLUSTRATIONS

1. Product leakage from bag valve while on conveyor

2. Laboratory test setup

3. Fan directions and locations used for blowing system tests

4. Dust monitoring locations used for field evaluation

5. Ventilation system used for test 2

6. Ventilation system used for test 3

TABLES

1. Average concentration from four sampling locations during laboratory testing

2. Dust reductions of field testing exhaust ventilation systems

A-1. Effect of blowing ventilation system with and without curtain

 
 
UNIT OF MEASURE ABBREVIATIONS USED IN THIS REPORT
 
cfm cubic foot per minute min minute
ft foot mg/m³ milligram per cubic meter
hp horsepower mm millimeter
in inch pct percent
lb pound ppm part per million


ABSTRACT

The Bureau of Mines has evaluated a number of ventilation systems for potential application in lowering the dust exposure of workers who stack bags of mineral product material in enclosed vehicles. Workers who stack these bags in enclosed vehicles usually have the highest dust exposure among all workers in processing plants. This is because dust liberated while the vehicle is being loaded has no means of exiting the vehicle or being diluted with fresh air and thus, dust concentrations increase to substantial levels. Laboratory-scale testing was performed in a railcar to compare the effectiveness of a number of different ventilation systems in reducing the bag stacker's dust exposure. The most effective system was taken into the field to optimize its performance. The final and recommended system exhausted about 2,000 cfm through 10-ft-long, 12-in diam fiberglass tubing located 3.5 ft past the slinger at a 6.5-ft height so as to not interfere with the bag stacker's job. A 6-in-diam tube exhausted approximately 300 cfm at the snake conveyor-slinger transfer point to capture the dust generated there. With this system, dust reductions in and around the bag stacker ranged between 65 and 95 pct when loading both 50- and 100-lb bags of product into railcars and trailer trucks.
 
INTRODUCTION

This report describes work the Bureau of Mines performed to determine a cost-effective system for ventilating enclosed vehicles as they exist today. Laboratory-scale testing was performed to determine the most effective system. This system was then tested at a mineral processing plant to optimize the technique in a working environment and to determine its effectiveness in lowering dust concentrations in enclosed vehicles during loading of bagged mineral product material.

Many mineral products are packaged in 50- or 100-lb paper bags. These bags are shipped to the customer on pallets, either in railcars or trailer trucks. Bags are either loaded by full pallets using a forklift, or directly by workers inside the vehicle, using a snake conveyor. The latter case is discussed in this report. Loading bags directly into enclosed vehicles is advantageous because it eliminates the forklift and operator. However, it is disadvantageous from a health standpoint because of the dust exposure to the stackers.

With direct loading, the bags travel down a flexible snake conveyor before passing into a device called a slinger, which can be raised and lowered to a convenient height for the workers unloading the bags. The stackers then take the bags from the slinger and hand-stack them onto pallets.

Except for minor effects owing to outside wind currents, there is no ventilation inside these vehicles. Any dust generated during the conveying and loading process remains within the vehicle and builds to substantial levels. This can become a serious health problem. The dust generated during loading can come from a number of different sources; the two main sources are product on the outside of the bag and leakage from the bag valve. Product on the outside of the bag is due to blowback (dust created as air and product are forced out of the bag as a result of excess pressure release from around the fill nozzle during filling); the "rooster tail" of product from both the fill nozzle and the bag valve during ejection from the filling machine, and product on the conveyor belt. Leakage from the bag valve occurs from movement on the conveyor as the bag travels to the loading area. This leakage can be substantial at conveyor transfer points and during the pallet loading process (fig. 1).

 
Back to Top Back to Top  www.osha.gov www.dol.gov

Contact Us | Freedom of Information Act | Information Quality | Customer Survey
Privacy and Security Statement | Disclaimers
Occupational Safety & Health Administration
200 Constitution Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20210